Winners of Best Play and Best Musical

Season 1
Best Play: Torch Song Trilogy
Best Musical: Best of Broadway: 2000-2009

Season 2
Best Play: For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When the Rainbow is Enuf
Best Musical: Children of Eden

Season 3
Best Play: Bus Stop
Best Musical: Spring Awakening

Season 4
Best Play: Bad Seed
Best Musical: Jesus Christ Superstar

Season 5
Best Play: Columbinus
Best Musical: Rent

Season 6
Best Play: The Great God Pan
Best Musical: Whistle a Happy Tune

Season 7
Best Play: As Is
Best Musical: Nunsense

Season 8
Best Play: Dearly Departed
Best Musical: The Bitch of Living, Teen Angst on Broadway

Season 9
Best Play: Murder in the First
Best Musical: Hair

Season 10
Best Play: Clown Bar
Best Musical: Best of Broadway: 1990-1995

Season 11
Best Play: The Christmas Bus
Best Musical: Broadway Retrospective, Years 6-10

Season 12
Best Play: With Their Eyes
Best Musical: Best of Broadway: 1985-1989

Season 13
Best Play: Elephant's Graveyard
Best Musical: In the Heights

Season 14
Best Play: Junie B. Jones in Jingle Bells, Batman Smells
Best Musical: Seussical

Season 15
Best Play: Reefer Madness
Best Musical: Disenchanted